Can one be a half-assed straight shooter?

He said, "I think I can get you half your money back. I want to get you in the mindset where you're recovering half of your losses." And followed that up with "I'm a straight shooter"

My response was this: "I don't want to tell you how to run your business. But it looks like I have to tell you to get into the mindset where I get all of my money back. If you only recover half of the money that CitiCorp Vendor Funding misappropriated from me, then you should seriously consider putting up the other half".

You want to think of yourself as a straight shooter? Put your money where your mouth is, that's what a straight-shooter would do.

I know because that is exactly what I would have done in the same situation, I've done exactly this kind of thing for my own customers.

In the past, We've gone out into the domain aftermarket and bought back a domain that a customer let lapse at our own expense. We did this a couple times even when we weren't sure it was our fault. When will we make our money back on that domain? Never. It'll take 60 or 100 years to recover that amount of margin. It doesn't matter.

We don't tell the customer "we'll get you half your domain name back, because we're straight shooters", that's a bullshit response.

Too many companies have a pointless aversion to going "out-of-pocket" when it comes to making amends. "Oh, I'll try to get you a refund from my subcontractor, but anything above that and I'll go out-of-pocket myself!" And? Your point is? Why should a pissed off customer care if you go out-of-pocket or not to fix something? Especially if you won't do it.

So to all self-avowed "straight-shooters" out there: Put your money where your mouth is. You either are or you're just talk. Time to mail this post to the president of my leasing company.